Maya returns to Princeton for her college reunion, looking forward to seeing old friends and attending her sister Naomi's graduation. However, her dream weekend turns into a nightmare when Naomi is found dead, and the police call it an accident. Maya suspects there's more to the story and starts uncovering details about Naomi’s life, revealing that she had joined Sterling Club, the exclusive social group Maya was once part of. As Maya digs deeper, she fears Naomi's decision to follow in her footsteps might have led to her death, especially since Naomi isn't the first woman to die under mysterious circumstances at Princeton. The investigation forces Maya to confront dark secrets from her own past.